Composite picture: T. rex courtesy of the ever generous public domain - Emile the rooster courtesy of Emile the rooster |
Here are some
statements for your consideration:
- “Tyrannosaurus rex was really just a big chicken.”
- “Chickens are the closest living relative to Tyrannosaurus rex.”
- “Chickens are directly descended from T. rex.”
- "Chickens are dinosaurs"
“Tyrannosaurus rex was really just a big chicken.” Seriously? The most basic comparison shows us that T. rex had “arms” and chickens have
wings. T. rex had a great gaping mouth filled with teeth. Chickens have beaks. So just no.
T. rex was definitely not a
chicken.
“Chickens are the closest living relative to Tyrannosaurus rex.” Well, that’s not a false statement, but it’s
very misleading. Here’s an analogy: Chimps
and humans share 96% of the same DNA—there’s obviously a close
relationship. So, to say humans are the
closest relative to chimps is a true statement.
To say that all of the citizens of Keokuk, Iowa are the closest
relatives to chimps is also true since all those fine people in Keokuk are
humans—but it puts a misleading spin on the truth. It sounds as though people from Keokuk are somehow more closely to chimps than other people are. Birds and T.
rex share some of the same genetic information (nowhere close to 96%, though), so
it is true to say that birds and T. rex
are related. It's even true to say that birds are the closest living relative to T. rex, even though they aren't that closely related. Saying chickens (a subset
of birds) and T. rex are closely
related takes us back to that misleading spin. Are chickens closer to T. rex than all other birds? Absolutely not! Let me beat you over the head with one more analogy and then I’ll move
on. Think of birds as jellybeans. Robins are cherry jellybeans, eagles are
licorice jellybeans, and chickens are lemon jellybeans. While there are obvious differences, they all
share traits so you can see them as all being members of the same larger
group. T. rex is a Snickers bar. He
is candy but he’s not a jellybean. There's a relationship but T. rex is not a
bird and definitely is not a chicken.
“Chickens are directly descended from T. rex.” Are they descended from
T. rex at all? In a word, no. In the scheme of animal classification, T. rex and all other tyrannosaurs as
well as chickens and all other birds all fit into the suborder Theropoda. Theropods
are a large and diverse group of animals that have hollow bones and three-toed
limbs in common. One subgroup of
therapods is the clade coelurosauria, and all birds and all tyrannosaurs belong
to this smaller group as well. Coelurosaurs have feathers in
common. Yup, tyrannosaurs had feathers—feathers
have already been found in two species and scientists suspect they were present somewhere on the bodies of all tyrannosaurs for at least part of their
lives. Within the coelurosauria there
are a number of subgroups—one is Tyrannosauroidea
that includes T. rex and all of his
cousins, another is Maniraptoriformes that includes chickens and all
other birds. These two groups split apart
a long, long time ago; waaay back in the Jurassic Period. Let’s just say that birds and tyrannosaurs are
at the same family reunion but on opposite ends of the table, and so T. rex, it turns out, was not grandpaw to chickens—he was more like a shirt-tail
relative.
“Chickens are dinosaurs.” Pretty much every evolutionary biologist and
paleontologist worth their salt long ago came to the conclusion that birds are
descended directly from dinosaurs. And
chickens, of course, are birds. Today it
has become generally accepted by scientists that birds are not descended from dinosaurs, but, in fact, are dinosaurs.
Around
66 million years ago there was a catastrophe that affected the whole
world—scientists are fairly certain that the actual event was a huge asteroid
or comet, perhaps ten miles wide, smashing into the Gulf of Mexico. In a very short period of time, referred to
by scientists as the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event, over three quarters
of the living species on Earth were wiped out—many insects, mammals, fish, plants,
and lizards were suddenly gone. Almost
every large animal disappeared, including T.
rex and every one of the other dinosaurs—except for one small group of smallish
therapods living on the southern continents—the birds. Afterwards, the few remaining birds and other
animals that survived spread across the world and evolved into the species we
have today. One bird that evolved in
Asia was the red junglefowl, and chickens are the domestic version of that
bird.
So,
there you have it. Next time you call
your chickens “little dinosaurs”, you can be sure that you’re being absolutely
correct. But calling your overly
aggressive rooster a T. rex is, well,
just taking it a bit too far.
Randy's Chicken Blog participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by linking to products available on Amazon.
No comments:
Post a Comment